Creamy Chicken Mushroom Pie

The smell of butter browning mushrooms always pulls me back to winter evenings in my tiny kitchen, standing over a skillet that was definitely too small for the job. I was trying to impress someone who said they didn't like pie, which felt like a challenge I couldn't ignore. The pastry puffed up golden and cracked just right, and when I cut into it, steam billowed out like I'd done something miraculous. They went quiet after the first bite, and I knew I'd won.

I made this for my neighbor once after she mentioned her mom used to make chicken pie every Sunday. She stood in my doorway holding the dish with both hands, eyes a little shiny, and told me it smelled exactly right. I didn't change a thing after that, because sometimes a recipe just lands where it's supposed to.

Ingredients

• Boneless, skinless chicken thighs or breasts: Thighs stay juicier and forgive you if you overcook them a little, but breasts work if that's what you have on hand.
• White or cremini mushrooms: Slice them thick so they hold their shape and get a real caramelized edge when you cook them down properly.
• Onion, garlic, and carrot: These build the base, the carrot adds a slight sweetness that balances the cream without announcing itself.
• Unsalted butter and olive oil: The butter gives you flavor, the oil keeps it from burning when you're browning the chicken hot and fast.
• All-purpose flour: This thickens the sauce just enough to coat the back of a spoon, no more.
• Chicken stock and heavy cream: Stock brings savoriness, cream makes it silky, together they turn into something you'll want to spoon over everything.
• Dijon mustard: Just a teaspoon sharpens the whole thing, cuts through the richness so it doesn't feel heavy.
• Ready-rolled puff pastry: Life is short, use the store-bought kind and save your energy for the filling.
• Egg for wash: Beaten with a fork, brushed on top, this is what gives you that bakery-level shine.
• Fresh parsley: Stir it in at the end for a hint of brightness that makes the whole dish feel alive.

Instructions

Preheat and Prep:

Get your oven to 200°C so it's ready when you need it. Dice your chicken into bite-sized pieces, nothing too small or they'll dry out.

Brown the Chicken:

Heat oil and butter until shimmering, add chicken with a good pinch of salt and pepper, let it sizzle without moving it for a minute so it gets color. Pull it out once it's golden but not cooked through, it'll finish later.

Cook the Vegetables:

Add the rest of the oil and butter, toss in onion, carrot, and garlic, let them soften and smell sweet. Throw in the mushrooms and don't stir too much, let them release their water and then brown in their own juice.

Build the Sauce:

Sprinkle flour over the vegetables, stir for a minute until it smells toasty. Pour in stock slowly, scraping up any brown bits stuck to the pan, then nestle the chicken back in.

Finish the Filling:

Stir in cream and mustard, let it bubble gently until the sauce coats a spoon and the chicken is cooked through. Add parsley, taste it, fix the seasoning, then pull it off the heat.

Assemble the Pie:

Spoon the filling into your pie dish and let it cool for ten minutes so the pastry doesn't turn soggy. Lay the pastry over the top, press the edges down with your fingers, trim the overhang, and cut a little slit in the middle for steam.

Bake:

Brush the top with beaten egg, slide it into the oven, and wait for it to puff and turn the color of toast. Let it rest for five minutes before you cut in, the filling needs a moment to settle.

Save to Pinterest

One night I served this to a friend who was going through a rough patch, and she ate two helpings without saying much. When she finally looked up, she just said, this is exactly what I needed, and I realized food doesn't always have to be fancy to matter. Sometimes it just has to be warm and generous and exactly right.

Make It Your Own

If you have leftover roast chicken or a rotisserie bird from the store, shred it and skip the browning step entirely, just fold it in with the cream. A splash of white wine added with the stock makes the sauce taste a little brighter, almost like it has a secret. You can swap the chicken for turkey, especially good the week after a holiday when you're drowning in leftovers and need something that feels new.

What to Serve Alongside

This pie is rich, so pair it with something crisp and green like steamed beans tossed with butter and lemon, or a simple salad with a sharp vinaigrette. Mashed potatoes feel like overkill, but if you want carbs, go for crusty bread to mop up any filling that escapes. A cold glass of white wine or even sparkling water with a slice of lemon keeps things balanced.

Storing and Reheating

Leftovers keep covered in the fridge for up to three days, and honestly they taste even better the next day once the flavors have mingled. Reheat individual portions in the oven at 180°C until warmed through and the pastry crisps back up, the microwave will make it soggy. You can freeze the assembled unbaked pie, just add ten extra minutes to the baking time and brush with egg wash right before it goes in.

• Wrap any leftover slices tightly in foil before refrigerating so the pastry doesn't dry out.
• If the top browns too fast while reheating, tent it loosely with foil halfway through.
• Label your freezer pie with the date and baking instructions, future you will thank you.

Save to Pinterest

This pie has pulled me through cold nights, surprise guests, and weeks when I needed something dependable and kind. I hope it does the same for you.

Frequently asked questions about this recipe

→ Can I substitute chicken with other meats?

Yes, turkey can be used as a substitute for chicken. Rotisserie chicken is also a convenient alternative to save preparation time.

→ What type of mushrooms work best in this dish?

White button or cremini mushrooms are ideal for their earthy flavor and texture that complement the creamy sauce well.

→ How do I achieve a flaky pastry crust?

Using ready-rolled puff pastry and brushing the top with beaten egg before baking helps create a golden, flaky crust.

→ Is there a way to enhance the sauce’s flavor?

Adding a splash of white wine to the chicken stock during cooking introduces depth and subtle acidity to the sauce.

→ What sides pair well with this savory pie?

Steamed green beans or a crisp leafy salad balance the richness of the pie with fresh, light flavors.